โ€“ Advertisement โ€“

Why Public Trust in the Church Continues to Erode

by | Jan 17, 2025 | News

โœช Read this article ad-free and leave comments here on Substack

For centuries, at least in the West, the church held an unparalleled position of trust and reverence. They were seen as the stewards of moral clarity in a world ever-increasing in cultural chaos. They were the shepherds who guided their flocks with conviction and commitment to the unchanging word of God.

In fact, as recently as 2009, more people in society trusted the clergy, but today? Well, letโ€™s just say that pollsters from Gallup have given us a brutal reality check, and the news isnโ€™t flattering.

Uploaded image

According to their latest survey, public trust in clergy has hit a historic low, with only 30% of Americans rating their honesty and ethics as โ€œhighโ€ or โ€œvery high.โ€ Compare that to 56% just two decades ago. What happened? Did the culture lose its moral compass? Orโ€”and this is the uncomfortable questionโ€”did the shepherds forget their job?

Letโ€™s be honest: you donโ€™t lose 26 percentage points in public trust overnight. It takes years of compromise, scandal, and outright failure to bring a once-respected institution to its knees. And clergyโ€”particularly those in the evangelical campโ€”have been working overtime to alienate the very people theyโ€™re supposed to serve.

Rather than standing firm on the rock of Scripture, too many church leaders have decided to plant their feet in the quicksand of cultural relevance. Whether it be The Gospel Coalition, the Southern Baptist Convention, or Christianity Today.

Join Us and Get These Perks:

โœ… No Ads in Articles
โœ… Access to Comments and Discussions
โœ… Community Chats
โœ… Full Article and Podcast Archive
โœ… The Joy of Supporting Our Work ๐Ÿ˜‰



Why preach conviction when you can pander? Why proclaim unpopular biblical truth when trendy platitudes will do? After all, isnโ€™t it easier to follow the culture than to confront it?

Letโ€™s chalk some of this decline up to the increasingly common public scandals that have plagued the pulpit. From tawdry sex scandals making headlines seemingly daily to embezzlement schemes that would make Wall Street blush, pastors have proven time and again that theyโ€™re just as susceptible to moral failure as the rest of us.

But when you claim to represent the eternal and holy God, your failures carry a weight that no financial guru or celebrity influencer could ever fathom. A scandal in the church isnโ€™t just a lapse in judgment, itโ€™s a betrayal of office on a cosmic scale.

And the public isnโ€™t stupid. They see the headlines, they hear the excuses, and they draw their own conclusions, these so-called men of God are no different from the rest of usโ€”maybe worse.

But scandals, as damaging as they are, are only part of the story. The deeper issue is the slow and steady erosion of conviction among church leaders. Too many pastors have traded the boldness of Paul for the cowardice of Pilate, washing their hands of controversy and refusing to take a stand.

Theyโ€™ve adopted the language of inclusivity, equity, and cultural sensitivity, all while abandoning the language of sin, repentance, and redemption.

Theyโ€™ve turned the gospelโ€”the good news that should turn the world upside downโ€”into a bland, inoffensive self-help message that wouldnโ€™t disturb a fly.

Is it any wonder the public no longer sees the clergy as a moral authority? How can they, when the pulpit has been reduced to a stage and the preacher to a performer?

And then thereโ€™s the golden calf of modern Evangelicalismโ€”relevancy. In their desperate bid to stay โ€œrelevant,โ€ the church has adopted the aesthetics of the culture while neglecting the substance of the gospel. Skinny jeans and smoke machines wonโ€™t save souls, but theyโ€™ve become the sacraments of a church more concerned with optics than orthodoxy.

Ironically, in trying to be relevant, the church has made itself irrelevant. After all, if the church is just a pale imitation of the world, why bother with it at all? If it offers nothing distinct, nothing transformative, why should anyone trust it?

The clergyโ€™s job isnโ€™t to reflect the culture, itโ€™s to confront it. Their calling isnโ€™t to make people comfortable, itโ€™s to make them holy. But too many pastors have forgotten that their role is not to be liked but to be faithful shepherds. Faithful to the word of God, faithful to their congregations, and faithful to the truth, even when itโ€™s unpopular. Especially when itโ€™s unpopular.

Truth is, trust is earned in ounces and lost in gallons. For centuries, the true church earned that trust through their commitment to a higher standard, their willingness to live lives of integrity and sacrifice, and their convictional proclamation of the gospel. But in recent years, theyโ€™ve squandered it.

And the publicโ€™s verdict is clear. Theyโ€™ve not merely fallen from grace, theyโ€™ve jumped willingly into the abyss, trading the eternal for the ephemeral and the holy for the superficial.

However, there is hope. God always maintains a remnant and the mission of the true Church is not hindered by cultural or public trust. His word will go forth, His gospel will be proclaimed, and Godโ€™s purpose will be done. In the end, this is simply purging by fire and purification of the churchโ€”and thatโ€™s when, historically, the true church has flourished the most.

Three Ways to Support DISNTR


The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


๐Ÿ‘• Or make a purchase from our online store. ๐Ÿ‘•
Make a Dogecoin Donation

- Advertisement -

Latest

Speaking the Truth in Lust

Speaking the Truth in Lust

Itโ€™s the darling phrase of modern Evangelicalismโ€”trotted out with breathless solemnity every time someone dares to speak a hard truth too plainly: โ€œWe must speak the truth in love.โ€ Four little words. A verse fragment. A harmless butterfly of a phrase that, somewhere...

Planned Parenthood Shouldnโ€™t Be Defunded, but the ERLC Should Be

Planned Parenthood Shouldnโ€™t Be Defunded, but the ERLC Should Be

I just read an โ€œexplainerโ€ article by the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission (ERLC) published in the Christian Index, and to no one's surprise, itโ€™s exactly what weโ€™ve come to expect from the Southern Baptist Conventionโ€™s well-funded public relations...

Your Internalized Homophobia Is Conviction of Sin

Your Internalized Homophobia Is Conviction of Sin

Editorโ€™s Note: The following article was submitted by a reader and is shared here in its entirety, exactly as it was received. It is a deeply personal testimony that engages candidly and biblically with a topic often clouded by confusion. While the views expressed are...

- Advertisement -

Subscribe

Store

Follow Us

- Advertisement -

- Advertisement -

You Might Also Likeโ€ฆ

Speaking the Truth in Lust

Speaking the Truth in Lust

Itโ€™s the darling phrase of modern Evangelicalismโ€”trotted out with breathless solemnity every time someone dares to speak a hard truth too plainly: โ€œWe must speak the truth in love.โ€ Four little words. A verse fragment. A harmless butterfly of a phrase that, somewhere...

Your Internalized Homophobia Is Conviction of Sin

Your Internalized Homophobia Is Conviction of Sin

Editorโ€™s Note: The following article was submitted by a reader and is shared here in its entirety, exactly as it was received. It is a deeply personal testimony that engages candidly and biblically with a topic often clouded by confusion. While the views expressed are...

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

I ran across a tweet the other day that lodged itself in my mind like a thorn. It was from Genevieve Gluck, a name that occasionally floats across the radar of gender-critical feminism, usually sounding some kind of alarm about the degradation of womanhood at the...

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

It started, as these things often do, with a simple question. A seemingly nice lady on Twitterโ€”yet a representative of the typical emotionally charged illogical reasoning of the mainstream pro-life movementโ€”wanted to know how I think my church should handle a woman in...

False Teacher of the Day #59: Kathryn Krick

False Teacher of the Day #59: Kathryn Krick

While we here at The Dissenter along with other discernment ministries have been sounding the alarm on her for some time, any False Teacher of the Day series would be woefully incomplete without a full expose on โ€œApostleโ€ Kathryn Krick. After all, this self-styled...

- Advertisement -

 

Want to go ad-free with exclusive content? Subscribe today.
Already a subscriber? Click Here

Three Ways to Support DISNTR



The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

 

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


๐Ÿ‘• Or make a purchase from our online store. ๐Ÿ‘•