โ€“ Advertisement โ€“

Christmas Hymn Review: Away in a Manger

by | Dec 17, 2024 | Opinion, Religion, The Church, Theology

โœช Read this article ad-free and leave comments here on Substack

Previously, I wrote an article calling for discernment while scrutinizing the lyrics of the popular Christmas song, Mary Did You Know? I knew it would be a provocative piece, as it was meant to be. However, my intent was not to dissuade you from enjoying these tunes, but rather to approach the lyrics with wisdom and discernment.

Christmas songs have a way of burrowing into our hearts, donโ€™t they? From the sweeping grandeur of O Holy Night to the cheerful jingles of Deck the Halls, these melodies become inseparable from the season itself. But sometimes, the words we sing betray theological missteps that go unnoticedโ€”because, letโ€™s face it, whoโ€™s stopping to dissect a carol when itโ€™s wrapped in nostalgia?

Just like the previous song I covered, Away in a Manger is another such song. For all its sentimentality, it subtly embeds ideas about Christ that crumble under the scrutiny of Scripture.

The origins of Away in a Manger are tangled in a bit of myth. It was long attributed to Martin Luther, the Protestant Reformer, and even labeled โ€œLutherโ€™s Cradle Hymn.โ€ But this claim is little more than a charming fiction.

Join Us and Get These Perks:

โœ… No Ads in Articles
โœ… Access to Comments and Discussions
โœ… Community Chats
โœ… Full Article and Podcast Archive
โœ… The Joy of Supporting Our Work ๐Ÿ˜‰



The song was first published in 1884 in the Little Childrenโ€™s Book for Schools and Families and set to music by William J. Kirkpatrick in 1895. Kirkpatrick, a Methodist hymn writer known for penning such classics as โ€˜Tis So Sweet to Trust in Jesus, was prolific but not without theological blind spots. And Away in a Mangerโ€”a sweet, childlike lullabyโ€”contains more than one.

On the surface, the songโ€™s simplicity is disarming. โ€œAway in a manger, no crib for a bed, the little Lord Jesus laid down His sweet head.โ€ It conjures a peaceful, idyllic image of the nativity, complete with starlit skies and gentle animals. But as the verses unfold, its sentimental veneer starts to show cracks. Letโ€™s take a closer look.

โ€œThe stars in the bright sky looked down where He lay, the little Lord Jesus asleep on the hay.โ€ A sweet image, but where in Scripture does it say the stars had anything to do with this moment? Itโ€™s poetic license, sureโ€”but it subtly embellishes the biblical narrative with fanciful details. Now, poetic imagery isnโ€™t inherently bad, but when songs become vehicles for unbiblical ideas, they risk skewing our understanding of the gospel.

Then comes this line: โ€œThe cattle are lowing, the Baby awakes, but little Lord Jesus, no crying He makes.โ€ Stop and think about that. A baby who doesnโ€™t cry? Who doesnโ€™t express the most basic human need? This seemingly innocent line introduces a theological problem so glaring, itโ€™s astonishing it has survived this long in Christian tradition. The line undermines one of the most essential truths about Christ, the hypostatic unionโ€”the reality that Jesus was fully God and fully man.

If Jesus didnโ€™t cry as a baby, what does that imply? That He wasnโ€™t fully human? That He didnโ€™t experience the range of human emotions or physical needs? Scripture tells us otherwise. Hebrews 2:17 says, โ€œTherefore He had to be made like His brothers in every respect, so that He might become a merciful and faithful high priest in the service of God, to make propitiation for the sins of the people.โ€

Every respect. Not some. Jesus cried. He hungered. He felt pain. He experienced anguish, and even prayed, asking His father to remove the forthcoming cup of wrath from Him if possible. The absence of these things would render Him less than humanโ€”and if He wasnโ€™t fully human, He couldnโ€™t fully atone for human sin.

Some may think this is just nitpicking, but I believe that without discernment, it opens the door to a theological landmine. By stripping Jesus of the most basic aspects of humanityโ€”like crying as an infantโ€”the song inadvertently suggests a sanitized, almost docetic version of Christ. Itโ€™s as if the baby in the manger was merely playing the part of a human while remaining aloof from human experience.

But the Scriptures tell a different story. Jesus wept (John 11:35). He groaned in His spirit (John 11:33). He sweat drops of blood in agony (Luke 22:44). These werenโ€™t theatrical displays of disingenuous human-like emotions, they were genuine human emotions and responses. To suggest otherwise is to chip away at the foundation of the incarnation itself.

The song concludes with a plea: โ€œBe near me, Lord Jesus, I ask You to stay, close by me forever, and love me, I pray.โ€ Itโ€™s heartfelt, to be sure, and thereโ€™s nothing wrong with praying for Jesusโ€™ presence in our lives. But by this point, the damage has already been done. The earlier lines have painted a picture of a Jesus who isnโ€™t quite humanโ€”a Jesus who doesnโ€™t cry, who seems untouched by the struggles of life. And this image, however unintentional, is at odds with the Jesus of the Bible.

Now, donโ€™t misunderstand meโ€”Iโ€™m not here to ruin Away in a Manger for anyone. Iโ€™m not suggesting you banish it from your Christmas playlist. But letโ€™s be clear about what it is. This song, like so many others, reflects a sentimentalized version of Christโ€™s birth, shaped more by Victorian ideals of innocence than by Scripture. In reality, the manger scene was probably replete with strong, unsanitary animal smells, a cool uncomfortable chill, and a tired, moody, worn-out teenage mother doing everything she could to appease a screaming baby.

This is not a hymn designed to teach doctrine or ground us in truth. Itโ€™s a lullabyโ€”simple, sweet, but theologically thin. So, if you sing it, sing it with discernment. Let it remind you not of an uncrying baby in a perfect nativity scene, but of the glorious reality that the Word became flesh and dwelt among us.

Jesus was fully God, yes, but He was also fully manโ€”a man who cried, who suffered, and who redeemed us through His humanity. Letโ€™s not trade that inexpressible truth for the sanitized emotionalism of a song. Christmas deserves better. So does Christ.

Three Ways to Support DISNTR


The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


๐Ÿ‘• Or make a purchase from our online store. ๐Ÿ‘•
Make a Dogecoin Donation

- Advertisement -

Latest

The Teen Who Waited Too Long to Murder Her Child is Sentenced

The Teen Who Waited Too Long to Murder Her Child is Sentenced

In a Nebraska courtroom, justice was finally dispensedโ€”but not in the way most would assume. Chloe Coplen-Anderson, now 18, was sentenced to 35 to 60 years in prison after being convicted of slitting her newborn sonโ€™s throat shortly after giving birth in her bedroom....

Anti-Trinitarian Heretic, TD Jakes is Stepping Down

Anti-Trinitarian Heretic, TD Jakes is Stepping Down

At long last, the velvet-tongued emperor of Christian celebrity culture, Bishop T.D. Jakes, has announced his exit from the pulpit of The Potterโ€™s Houseโ€”the crumbling empire he built atop the rotting carcass of the Word of Faith movement and anti-Trinitarian heresy....

False Teacher of the Day #62: Levi Lusko

False Teacher of the Day #62: Levi Lusko

Levi Lusko has built a reputation as the quintessential hip, modern megachurch pastorโ€”tattoos, trendy sneakers, polished storytelling, and a high-production platform that attracts the crowds and flatters the culture. But beneath the fashionable exterior and charming...

- Advertisement -

Subscribe

Store

Follow Us

- Advertisement -

- Advertisement -

You Might Also Likeโ€ฆ

The Teen Who Waited Too Long to Murder Her Child is Sentenced

The Teen Who Waited Too Long to Murder Her Child is Sentenced

In a Nebraska courtroom, justice was finally dispensedโ€”but not in the way most would assume. Chloe Coplen-Anderson, now 18, was sentenced to 35 to 60 years in prison after being convicted of slitting her newborn sonโ€™s throat shortly after giving birth in her bedroom....

Anti-Trinitarian Heretic, TD Jakes is Stepping Down

Anti-Trinitarian Heretic, TD Jakes is Stepping Down

At long last, the velvet-tongued emperor of Christian celebrity culture, Bishop T.D. Jakes, has announced his exit from the pulpit of The Potterโ€™s Houseโ€”the crumbling empire he built atop the rotting carcass of the Word of Faith movement and anti-Trinitarian heresy....

False Teacher of the Day #62: Levi Lusko

False Teacher of the Day #62: Levi Lusko

Levi Lusko has built a reputation as the quintessential hip, modern megachurch pastorโ€”tattoos, trendy sneakers, polished storytelling, and a high-production platform that attracts the crowds and flatters the culture. But beneath the fashionable exterior and charming...

False Teacher of the Day #61: Craig Groeschel

False Teacher of the Day #61: Craig Groeschel

He walks onto the stage with a flawless smile and a perfectly-timed pause. The lights dim, the audience leans in, and for thirty minutes, the man speaks with the cadence of a TED Talker and the certainty of a Silicon Valley mogul pitching salvation like a subscription...

The Pontiff Has Fallenโ€”And He Will Not Rise Again

The Pontiff Has Fallenโ€”And He Will Not Rise Again

The pontiff is dead. And no, the bells arenโ€™t ringing in triumphโ€”theyโ€™re tolling like a funeral dirge for a man whose soul now quakes before the throne of Almighty God. Pope Francisโ€”Romeโ€™s darling, the mediaโ€™s mascot, the Church of Niceโ€™s poster boyโ€”is gone. And what...

- Advertisement -

 

Want to go ad-free with exclusive content? Subscribe today.
Already a subscriber? Click Here

Three Ways to Support DISNTR



The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

 

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


๐Ÿ‘• Or make a purchase from our online store. ๐Ÿ‘•