– Advertisement –

Breaking Down Andy Stanley’s Latest Heresy

by | Dec 2, 2024 | News

✪ Read this article ad-free and leave comments here on Substack

In Andy Stanley’s latest sermon, he makes several claims that are either outright heretical or lead to heresy when taken to its logical conclusion. I would like to break these claims down and address them point by point.

“When the New Testament authors began writing, they didn’t know they were writing the New Testament.”

While it’s true that the New Testament authors may not have initially recognized their writings as what we now call the New Testament canon, this statement downplays the doctrine of divine inspiration. Scripture is clear that the authors of both the Old and New Testaments wrote under the direct inspiration of the Holy Spirit (2 Peter 1:21; 2 Timothy 3:16). To suggest they were merely “documenting what they experienced” risks reducing their writings to human reflections rather than divinely inspired revelation.

“God does not need us to make excuses for him. He doesn’t expect us to explain or explain away his Old Testament behavior.”

This statement deceptively implies that God’s actions in the Old Testament need justification or might be viewed as morally questionable. This creates a false dichotomy between the Old and New Testaments, suggesting that the God of the Old Testament is less palatable or needs rebranding. It disregards the unity and immutability of God’s nature (Malachi 3:6; Hebrews 13:8).

“In the Old Testament, we find God playing by the rules of the kingdoms of this world to prepare for a time when he would introduce a kingdom, not of this world.”

This assertion implies that God’s actions in the Old Testament were somehow constrained or dictated by worldly systems. This diminishes God’s sovereignty and omnipotence, suggesting He needed to “play by the rules” of human kingdoms. Scripture, however, consistently presents God as sovereign over all nations and kingdoms, operating according to His perfect will and plan (Daniel 4:35; Psalm 115:3).

Join Us and Get These Perks:

✅ No Ads in Articles
✅ Access to Comments and Discussions
✅ Community Chats
✅ Full Article and Podcast Archive
✅ The Joy of Supporting Our Work 😉



As is typical with his sermons, the overarching theme of Stanley’s rhetoric suggests a discontinuity between the Old and New Testaments, framing them as two contrasting revelations. This is a foundational error that ignores the progressive revelation of Scripture, where the Old Testament lays the groundwork for the New Testament (Luke 24:27; Matthew 5:17). To portray the Old Testament as merely preparatory or as a foil to the New undermines its authority and significance.

By focusing on God “preparing for a time” and “playing by the rules,” Stanley fails to recognize that Christ and the gospel are central throughout the Old Testament (John 5:39; Hebrews 10:1). The sacrificial system, the law, and the prophecies all point to the coming Messiah. God’s “behavior” in the Old Testament is not arbitrary or dictated by worldly norms—it is a revelation of His nature and character. It’s a revelation of His holiness, justice, and mercy.

Three Ways to Support DISNTR


The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


👕 Or make a purchase from our online store. 👕
Make a Dogecoin Donation

- Advertisement -

Latest

False Teacher of the Day #63: Delman Coates

False Teacher of the Day #63: Delman Coates

Delman Coates, the senior pastor of Mt. Ennon Baptist Church, recently delivered a sermon that could only be described as theological arson. Coates didn't just bend the truth—he violently assaulted it, dragged it into a dark alley, and left it bleeding. He essentially...

We Need to Address the Church’s Bondage to Hollywood

We Need to Address the Church’s Bondage to Hollywood

If our church members fall into the habit of frequenting the theatre, we shall soon have them going much further in the direction of vice, and they will lose all relish for the ways of God. If theatre-going became general among professing Christians, it would be the...

- Advertisement -

Subscribe

Store

Follow Us

- Advertisement -

- Advertisement -

You Might Also Like…

False Teacher of the Day #63: Delman Coates

False Teacher of the Day #63: Delman Coates

Delman Coates, the senior pastor of Mt. Ennon Baptist Church, recently delivered a sermon that could only be described as theological arson. Coates didn't just bend the truth—he violently assaulted it, dragged it into a dark alley, and left it bleeding. He essentially...

We Need to Address the Church’s Bondage to Hollywood

We Need to Address the Church’s Bondage to Hollywood

If our church members fall into the habit of frequenting the theatre, we shall soon have them going much further in the direction of vice, and they will lose all relish for the ways of God. If theatre-going became general among professing Christians, it would be the...

Dear Effeminate Pastor, Here’s Why You’re Bleeding Men

Dear Effeminate Pastor, Here’s Why You’re Bleeding Men

Dear Effeminate Pastor, You stand on a stage, not a pulpit. Beneath theatrical lights, not the burning fire of truth. Draped in pastel rebellion and accessorized like a department store mannequin on discount, you glide across the platform like a self-help seminar host...

The Gospel According to Karl Marx

The Gospel According to Karl Marx

Karl Marx was not just some economist scribbling theories in obscurity who happened to have a stroke of luck in becoming a household name—he was the architect of a worldview that treats envy as virtue, revolution as redemption, and the State as god. What began in the...

If Evangelicals Want to Become Catholic, We Should Let Them Go

If Evangelicals Want to Become Catholic, We Should Let Them Go

Let them go. Really, let them. If your spiritual appetite can be satisfied by the incense-choked pageantry of Rome—by genuflecting before a golden cage of transubstantiated flour—then it was never Christ that you hungered for to begin with. If you're willing to trade...

- Advertisement -

Want to go ad-free with exclusive content? Subscribe today.
Already a subscriber? Click Here

Three Ways to Support DISNTR



The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

 

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


👕 Or make a purchase from our online store. 👕