- Advertisement -

The Church’s Debate Over Christian Nationalism: Should We Embrace Cultural Christianity?

- Advertisement -

As the modern Church is now faced with its own internal debate of Christian Nationalism, we should examine how the multifaceted world of “cultural Christianity” has been a paradoxical force that can both benefit and challenge us. As we traverse the shifting sands of our modern society, it behooves us to pause and ponder the implications of this pervasive phenomenon, weighing the pros and cons with sober judgment and keen discernment.

To fully grasp the intricacies of this enigmatic conundrum, we must cast our gaze backward through the mists of time, to an era when the Bible Belt reigned supreme as a bastion of Christian culture and influence. In those halcyon days, we often found the teachings of Scripture interwoven into the very fabric of society, providing a moral compass and a guiding light for a people striving to live in accordance with the dictates of their faith.

In that bygone age, the Bible Belt served as a powerful example of the potential impact that cultural Christianity can have upon a nation, fostering a sense of unity, purpose, and shared values among its adherents. However, it is important to acknowledge that these benefits were not uniformly experienced across all communities, as race and class divisions persisted in many areas. While the authority of the church was well-respected and revered by many as a force for good and a stabilizing influence, it is important to recognize the historical context and complexities that shaped the lives of people during that time.

As we delve deeper into the annals of history, we also discern the shadows that lurked beneath the surface of this seemingly idyllic vision. For within the halls of the Bible Belt’s cultural Christianity, the seeds of complacency, hypocrisy, and spiritual stagnation were sown, threatening to undermine the very foundations of the faith they sought to uphold.

On the one hand, cultural Christianity, when embraced by the masses, can indeed serve as a bulwark against the encroaching tide of moral decay that threatens to engulf our beleaguered nation. Imagine, if you will, a society where the majority of its citizens adhere, at least nominally, to the tenets of the Christian faith. Such a world would be characterized by a modicum of stability and a semblance of moral order, a place where the virtues of honesty, integrity, and selflessness still hold sway, and where the bonds of family and community remain strong and unbreakable.

In this envisioned society, the LGBTQ movement, which has taken on the characteristics of a religion in and of itself, would not hold the final authority over cultural values and norms and the push for the normalization of various sexual orientations and gender identities would be tempered by the traditional Christian understanding of marriage and family. Likewise, the mass slaughter of millions of innocent children in the wombs, tragically commonplace in our current society, would not be brushed over or accepted as a necessary evil. Instead, the sanctity of life would be upheld, and the unborn would be recognized as deserving of protection and care.

Indeed, in such a world, one could argue that the rampant hedonism, relativism, and nihilism that plague our current age would be held at bay, allowing for the flourishing of a more just, more honest, and less morally corrupt society. Cultural Christianity, in this sense, could only serve as a vital force for good and a beacon of light amidst the encroaching darkness.

Join Us and Get These Perks:

✅ No Ads in Articles
✅ Access to Comments and Discussions
✅ Community Chats
✅ Full Article and Podcast Archive
✅ The Joy of Supporting Our Work 😉

However, let’s not be misled by the allure of this seemingly idyllic vision, as there are hidden dangers beneath the surface, and subtle pitfalls that could trap the unsuspecting person on their journey of faith. The widespread acceptance of cultural Christianity carries with it the pernicious risk of obscuring the line between the genuine followers of Christ, the “sheep,” and those who merely pay lip service to the faith, the dreaded “goats.”

In a society steeped in cultural Christianity, it becomes all too easy for the masses to mistake mere outward conformity for true, heartfelt devotion to the Lord. The external trappings of faith—church attendance, charitable giving, and public displays of piety—are often mistaken for the fruits of a genuine relationship with Christ. In this snare, countless souls may be led astray, lulled into a false sense of security, and robbed of the opportunity to truly experience the life-changing power of a true encounter with the living God through the gospel of Jesus Christ.

So, what are we, as Christians, to make of this double-edged sword that is cultural Christianity? How do we navigate the treacherous waters that lie between the Scylla of moral decay and the Charybdis of spiritual complacency?

The answer, fellow believers, lies in our unwavering commitment to the true, unadulterated Gospel of Christ, and in our steadfast refusal to compromise the eternal truths of Scripture for the sake of mere outward appearances. Of course, we seek to create a more just society by supporting laws, policies, and politicians that will uphold decency and moral order to the best of our ability. And, of course, we seek to protect the freedom to worship Christ enshrined in our nation’s founding documents. But we must recognize that the revitalization of America is not the end goal of the gospel—Jesus’s kingdom is not of this world.

We must strive to be genuine ambassadors of Christ, shining the light of His love and truth into the darkest corners of our society, and boldly proclaiming the message of salvation to a lost and dying world. We must resist the temptation to embrace cultural Christianity as a panacea for the ills of our society, recognizing that the only true and lasting solution lies in the transformation of individual hearts and lives through the power of the Holy Spirit. And we must remain ever vigilant, discerning the difference between the sheep and the goats, and exhorting our fellow believers to press on towards the goal of knowing Christ and making Him known.

In so doing, we may yet hope to see the dawning of a new day, a day when the true, living Church of Christ stands as a beacon of hope, righteousness, and truth in a world beset by darkness, despair, and deception.

This post is merely my opinion, subject to change at any time without notice, and your opinion may be completely different—and that’s okay!


Big Tech is cracking down on conservative blogs like ours. To make sure you continue to access our work, please subscribe to our newsletter.

Our continued work is dependent on supporters like you. Become a member and get all of our exclusive content, ad-free! Or you can make a one-time donation to support our work!


Join our ad-free Substack community to read and post comments...

- Advertisement -


Our very existence is under attack! Big tech is trying to silence us and stamp out our conservative biblical worldview. But we won't go down without a fight. Subscribe to stay in informed!

- Advertisement -


- Advertisement -

Also Read


- Advertisement -

Already a member? Click Here