โ€“ Advertisement โ€“

Women in Southern Baptist Pulpits? Southern Baptists, You Own This

by | Aug 19, 2024 | Feminism, Opinion, Religion, Social Justice, Social-Issues, The Church

โœช Read this article ad-free and leave comments here on Substack

In June 2023, the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) appeared to take what we thought might be a decisive stand against the creeping influence of progressivism within its ranks by voting to amend its constitution to explicitly ban women pastors. What turned out to be nothing more than a mirage, many believed this would solidify the denominationโ€™s commitment to biblical authority, signaling a firm rejection of the feminist ideology that had been gradually infiltrating the church. But that sense of victory was short-lived.

Fast forward to June 2024, and the SBCโ€™s so-called resolve buckled under pressure. Denominational leadersโ€”JD Greear, Rick Warren, and their ilkโ€”led the charge to overturn the amendment. Their campaign succeeded, and when the amendment required a second vote to become permanent, it was struck down, leaving the SBCโ€™s supposed commitment in tatters.

But letโ€™s not pretend this wasnโ€™t expected. Southern Baptists have been swooning over lady-preachers for years. Beth Mooreโ€”who personifies the SBCโ€™s infatuation with egalitarianismโ€”was given the stage time and time again to peddle her false teachings.

The SBCโ€™s love affair with Moore was marked by endless adulation and endorsement from the loudest corners of the denomination. But in a classic twist of poetic irony, the very institution that lifted her up couldnโ€™t satisfy her demands. Why? Because for Moore, anything less than total, unquestioning endorsement was never going to suffice, and there were still a few voices of dissent leftโ€”though their numbers were dwindling.

In the end, Moore stormed out of the SBC, not content with mere toleranceโ€”like any good progressive, she craved celebration. And when the SBC wavered, she walked away, proving that all their compromises had been utterly pointless.

But Beth Moore was just the beginning. The SBCโ€™s affection toward women preachersโ€”whether it be Moore, Jen Wilkin, or Christine Caine, who regularly visits Southern Baptist churches to preachโ€”goes deeper and darker. Over the years, weโ€™ve seen countless examples of women being elevated to the pulpit in Southern Baptist churchesโ€”despite the denominationโ€™s official statement of faith stating that the office of pastor is biblically reserved for men.

Fellowship Church had Lisa Young preaching regularly, and even the North American Mission Boardโ€™s (NAMB) church plant, Echo Church, let โ€œPastorโ€ Stacie Wood take the stage. And letโ€™s not forget Saddleback Church, Rick Warrenโ€™s brainchild, which famously ordained three women pastors.

And while the SBC did choose to remove Saddleback Church from disfellowship prior to overturning the constitutional amendment to disallow women pastors, clearly, since then, the sentiment has changed thanks to the efforts of men like Greear. One has to wonder: if given another chance in todayโ€™s SBC climate, would Saddleback be allowed back?

Image

Here we stand in 2024, and the Southern Baptist Convention has officially taken a knee before the altar of feminism. With the constitutional amendment trashed, the floodgates are flung wide open, inviting women like Christine Caine to step into the pulpit without a second thought.

The Bibleโ€™s stance on women preachers? Crystal clear. And while I usually steer clear of the โ€œslippery slopeโ€ tropeโ€”favoring rock-solid, indisputable truthโ€”this isnโ€™t just a slope, itโ€™s an avalanche, sweeping everything in its path. The SBC is barreling down the same reckless path as the United Methodist Church, where the lines blur, and anything goes. Women pastors? Already a done deal. Whatโ€™s next? Queers in the pulpit? Donโ€™t bet against itโ€”itโ€™s already been flirted with.

Join Us and Get These Perks:

โœ… No Ads in Articles
โœ… Access to Comments and Discussions
โœ… Community Chats
โœ… Full Article and Podcast Archive
โœ… The Joy of Supporting Our Work ๐Ÿ˜‰



Southern Baptists, you own this. You have no one to blame but yourselves. You flirted with egalitarianism, and now youโ€™re married to it. Christine Caineโ€™s appearance in the pulpit at Church by the Glades is just a preview of whatโ€™s to come. These churches are not churches at all and they are just lifting their proverbial middle fingers to the Scripturesโ€”and you didnโ€™t care.

The floodgates are open, and the waters of compromise are rushing in. The SBC is drowning in its own cowardice, and itโ€™s taking the last remaining faithful churches in the denomination down with it. God help us all.

Three Ways to Support DISNTR


The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


๐Ÿ‘• Or make a purchase from our online store. ๐Ÿ‘•
Make a Dogecoin Donation

- Advertisement -

Latest

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

I ran across a tweet the other day that lodged itself in my mind like a thorn. It was from Genevieve Gluck, a name that occasionally floats across the radar of gender-critical feminism, usually sounding some kind of alarm about the degradation of womanhood at the...

David French, Russell Moore, and the Politics of Selective Compassion

David French, Russell Moore, and the Politics of Selective Compassion

I ran across a tweet by Elon Musk this morning that got me thinkingโ€”a rare moment of clarity slicing through the pious fog of evangelical open-borderism. It showed a crowd of South African leftistsโ€”dressed in their standard-issue revolutionary cosplayโ€”chanting in...

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

It started, as these things often do, with a simple question. A seemingly nice lady on Twitterโ€”yet a representative of the typical emotionally charged illogical reasoning of the mainstream pro-life movementโ€”wanted to know how I think my church should handle a woman in...

False Teacher of the Day #59: Kathryn Krick

False Teacher of the Day #59: Kathryn Krick

While we here at The Dissenter along with other discernment ministries have been sounding the alarm on her for some time, any False Teacher of the Day series would be woefully incomplete without a full expose on โ€œApostleโ€ Kathryn Krick. After all, this self-styled...

- Advertisement -

Subscribe

Store

Follow Us

- Advertisement -

- Advertisement -

You Might Also Likeโ€ฆ

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

I ran across a tweet the other day that lodged itself in my mind like a thorn. It was from Genevieve Gluck, a name that occasionally floats across the radar of gender-critical feminism, usually sounding some kind of alarm about the degradation of womanhood at the...

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

It started, as these things often do, with a simple question. A seemingly nice lady on Twitterโ€”yet a representative of the typical emotionally charged illogical reasoning of the mainstream pro-life movementโ€”wanted to know how I think my church should handle a woman in...

False Teacher of the Day #59: Kathryn Krick

False Teacher of the Day #59: Kathryn Krick

While we here at The Dissenter along with other discernment ministries have been sounding the alarm on her for some time, any False Teacher of the Day series would be woefully incomplete without a full expose on โ€œApostleโ€ Kathryn Krick. After all, this self-styled...

Defying Rome: Wear Orange on St. Patrickโ€™s Day

Defying Rome: Wear Orange on St. Patrickโ€™s Day

Every year, as March 17th rolls around, we're smothered beneath an avalanche of greenโ€”green beer, green shamrocks, green everythingโ€”as if someone accidentally detonated a giant Leprechaun-themed confetti bomb. Amid this nauseating sea of verdant monotony, a dissenting...

- Advertisement -

 

Want to go ad-free with exclusive content? Subscribe today.
Already a subscriber? Click Here

Three Ways to Support DISNTR



The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

 

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


๐Ÿ‘• Or make a purchase from our online store. ๐Ÿ‘•