– Advertisement –

Moody Pastor Says Mary “Gave Her Consent” to Conceive Jesus

by | Jan 9, 2025 | News

✪ Read this article ad-free and leave comments here on Substack

Philip Miller, the current pastor of Moody Church in Chicago, succeeded the long-tenured Erwin Lutzer, is bringing his own pastoral approach to the historic pulpit by weaving contemporary social themes into his preaching. Before Christmas, Miller preached a sermon out of Luke 1 that characterized Mary’s response to the angel Gabriel as “giving her consent” to God’s plan for the Incarnation.

Watch:

Moody Pastor Says Mary “Gave Her Consent” to Conceive Jesus https://thedissenter.substack.com/p/moody-pastor-says-mary-gave-her-consent

– Jeff

Join Us and Get These Perks:

✅ No Ads in Articles
✅ Access to Comments and Discussions
✅ Community Chats
✅ Full Article and Podcast Archive
✅ The Joy of Supporting Our Work 😉



Read on Substack

The claim that Mary “gave her consent” to conceive Jesus is a common claim in some modern evangelical circles, particularly those who are beholden to the modern woke ideologies of agency and consent. However, such a statement is not supported by a cursory reading of the biblical text or a proper understanding of the sovereignty of God. This interpretation arises from a desire to project modern ideas about personal autonomy and consent onto ancient, biblical narratives.

In Luke 1:26-38, the angel Gabriel announces to Mary that she will conceive and bear a son, Jesus, by the power of the Holy Spirit. Mary’s response—”Behold, I am the servant of the Lord; let it be to me according to your word” (Luke 1:38, ESV)—is an expression of humble submission to God’s will, not a negotiation or granting of consent. Nowhere in the text is Mary portrayed as having the authority to approve or disapprove of God’s plan. Rather, her response reflects a heart of faith and obedience to God’s sovereign decree.

To suggest that Mary “gave her consent” to conceive Jesus isn’t just careless theology, it’s an intentional, calculated move to impose a modern, autonomy-obsessed framework onto the eternal and sovereign work of God. This isn’t a rookie mistake from an undertrained preacher—Miller is fully aware of the theological weight of his words. The only question is: why?

Three Ways to Support DISNTR


The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


👕 Or make a purchase from our online store. 👕
Make a Dogecoin Donation

- Advertisement -

Latest

Speaking the Truth in Lust

Speaking the Truth in Lust

It’s the darling phrase of modern Evangelicalism—trotted out with breathless solemnity every time someone dares to speak a hard truth too plainly: “We must speak the truth in love.” Four little words. A verse fragment. A harmless butterfly of a phrase that, somewhere...

- Advertisement -

Subscribe

Store

Follow Us

- Advertisement -

- Advertisement -

You Might Also Like…

Speaking the Truth in Lust

Speaking the Truth in Lust

It’s the darling phrase of modern Evangelicalism—trotted out with breathless solemnity every time someone dares to speak a hard truth too plainly: “We must speak the truth in love.” Four little words. A verse fragment. A harmless butterfly of a phrase that, somewhere...

Your Internalized Homophobia Is Conviction of Sin

Your Internalized Homophobia Is Conviction of Sin

Editor’s Note: The following article was submitted by a reader and is shared here in its entirety, exactly as it was received. It is a deeply personal testimony that engages candidly and biblically with a topic often clouded by confusion. While the views expressed are...

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

Surrogacy is The Childless Gospel of the Left

I ran across a tweet the other day that lodged itself in my mind like a thorn. It was from Genevieve Gluck, a name that occasionally floats across the radar of gender-critical feminism, usually sounding some kind of alarm about the degradation of womanhood at the...

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

A Response to Twitter Thread on Capital Punishment for Abortions

It started, as these things often do, with a simple question. A seemingly nice lady on Twitter—yet a representative of the typical emotionally charged illogical reasoning of the mainstream pro-life movement—wanted to know how I think my church should handle a woman in...

- Advertisement -

 

Want to go ad-free with exclusive content? Subscribe today.
Already a subscriber? Click Here

Three Ways to Support DISNTR



The Dissenter is primarily supported by its readers. The best way to support us is to subscribe to our members-only Substack site where you will receive all of our content ad-free, plus you will get member-only exclusive content.

 

Support us with a monthly donation on Patreon

Support us with membership to our ad-free Substack

Make one-time or monthly donation on Donorbox


👕 Or make a purchase from our online store. 👕